Japanese vs. English Pokémon Cards – Which Should You Collect?

Introduction

If you're new to collecting or even a seasoned fan, you've probably wondered:
Should I collect Japanese or English Pokémon cards?

Both versions have their strengths, and the best choice really depends on what you're looking for—aesthetic appeal, investment potential, rarity, or personal nostalgia.

In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of Japanese vs. English Pokémon cards so you can decide which is the better fit for your collection.

1. Print Quality

-Japanese Pokémon Cards:

  • Sharper lines, richer color, and superior print finish.

  • Better centering and cutting, which leads to higher PSA/BGS grades.

  • Use premium card stock with a smoother, glossier surface.

-English Pokémon Cards:

  • Inconsistent print runs, sometimes with whitening, poor centering, or duller colors.

  • Made with slightly different materials that can affect how the card ages over time.

🎯 Winner: Japanese cards for quality and long-term durability.

2. Release Schedule & Exclusivity

-Japanese Cards:

  • Always released months before their English counterparts.

  • Feature exclusive sets, promos, and art that never appear in English.

  • Example: The Pokémon Card 151 set and the Poncho Pikachu promos are Japan-only releases.

-English Cards:

  • Often based on combined or altered Japanese sets.

  • May remove cards or alter artwork during translation.

🎯 Winner: Japanese cards for early access and exclusive collector’s value.

3. Artwork & Text

-Japanese Cards:

  • Often feature unique or alternate artwork.

  • Text is in Japanese, which adds aesthetic appeal and authenticity for many collectors.

-English Cards:

  • Easier to read and understand—ideal for players who participate in English-language tournaments.

  • Some collectors may prefer having card effects written in their own language.

🎯 Tie – Depends on whether you prioritize readability or artistic authenticity.

4. Rarity and Value

-Japanese Cards:

  • Certain promos and rare pulls are limited to Japan, increasing scarcity.

  • Due to quality and exclusivity, Japanese cards often retain or gain value faster—especially in high grades.

-English Cards:

  • Still valuable, especially vintage sets like Base Set and Neo series.

  • More widely available, which can affect long-term rarity.

🎯 Winner: Japanese cards for long-term value and rarity.

5. Availability and Price

-English Cards:

  • More accessible in the West, often found in local game stores or retail outlets.

  • Easier for kids and casual collectors to obtain.

-Japanese Cards:

  • Must be imported or bought through trusted Japanese Pokémon card stores (like TallyTCG).

  • Shipping and international demand can affect prices, but they often remain competitive.

🎯 Winner: English cards for accessibility, Japanese cards for serious collectors.

So… Which Should You Choose?

If you’re a casual player or new collector, English cards may feel more familiar and easier to start with.
But if you’re looking for:

  • Higher-grade quality

  • Exclusive sets and promos

  • Long-term value

  • Artistic and cultural authenticity

... then Japanese Pokémon cards are the superior choice.

At TallyTCG, we specialize in offering authentic Japanese Pokémon cards, including hard-to-find promos, booster boxes, and collector favorites

Back to blog